
Líchvod Ha-Torah seminar reaction
paper
-
WHY? Writing down our reactions to an event helps us to be
more attentive to what we think and feel about it. The field trips
involve a number of experiences which may evoke different feelings for
different participants. Mulling over your feelings and thoughts will
help you to sort out the religious, social and cultural "rules" which you
take for granted. This heightened awareness makes it possible to compare
and contrast your assumptions with those of other religious traditions,
and to evaluate critically the benefits and drawbacks of each set.
-
FOR WHOM? The process is to help you; the product
is for your classmates and instructor.
-
HOW? Prepare to write by brainstorming on the following topics:
-
What did you expect to see & hear during the tour and seminar?
-
What did you actually see and notice?
-
What were your surprises and insights?
-
What unique features of Judaism did you discover (or re-discover) through
this field trip?
-
What similarities did you find between Judaism and your own religious tradition?
-
What connections do you see between your field trip insights and the course
material so far (esp. the readings)?
-
What further questions did this experience raise for you?
-
WHAT? Choose one of the unique features of Judaism or one
of the similarities you noted in #3.4-6. Decide why you think this
is the most significant insight from this field experience. Then begin
to organize the data from #3 to support your contention. Your actual
paper will follow the basic three-part formula: Introduction, Body,
Conclusion.
-
the Introduction includes two things: your thesis concerning the most significant
insight from this field experience, and the basic outline of how
you will present your case.
-
the Body is where you lay out your argument, step-by-step, showing your
audience why your thesis should be upheld; include details from the experience
and readings wherever possible, and show why it is essential for understanding
the content of this class.
-
the Conclusion contains two things: your summary of how you have established
your thesis, and further questions you would like to investigate.
If you choose, you also can include a prediction of further effects of
the experience on your thinking and/or behavior.
-
FORMAT? When referring to text books, parenthetical notes
with the short title and page numbers are fine. For outside sources,
footnotes are preferable. NB: For web sources, be sure to cite your
access date and time.
-
LENGTH? Two or three double-spaced pages should suffice.
Please use a 10-12 point font, and maintain one-inch margins all around.
-
EVALUATION? An "A" paper will present a clear and concise
statement of your analysis of the experience. It will be written in formal
English that is a pleasure to read. It will be free of any typographical,
grammatical, and orthographical errors. It will draw interesting
connections between the field activity and the readings to date.
The paper will follow a linear development, from the introduction through
the body to the conclusion. It will culminate in a discussion of
the religious and social implications you see based on the experience and
the course readings so far.