Verbatim Reports
Grading Protocol
last update: 07 April 2008
PART I: Observation

During the event and immediately following, write as complete and accurate a description of the event as you can. Include every factor you see as relevant, while omitting extraneous ones. Include descriptions of:

  /05 points 1. The architectural features of the site or building
  /05 points 2. Physical arrangements, colors and ornamentation of any furnishings
  /05 points 3. Leaders and participants in the event--their sex, age, dress, speech, actions, location, etc.
  /05 points 4. What the ritual means to the participants you are observing
  /05 points 5. Whatever else you think is of importance
PART II: Analysis, Reflection & Evaluation

A. Analysis

  /05 points 6. What actions, persons, places and things seemed the most important? Why?
  /05 points 7. What actions, persons, places and things seemed the least important, or even superfluous? Why?
  /05 points 8. What connections do you see between the verbal & ritual aspects of this event?
  /05 points 9. What connections do you see among the ritual actions? What do you see as the basic "ritual process" for this event?

B. Theological reflection

  /05 points 10. What signs and symbols can you identify in this ritual?
  /05 points 11 .What do these signs and symbols mean/convey?
  /05 points 12. What kind of ritual is this? Why would you classify it this way?
  /05 points 13. What does this ritual teach (e.g., about human nature, the divine, the natural world, the assembly of believers)? How does your reflection compare and contrast with what the participants said it means?
  /05 points 14. How (i.e., by what means) does this ritual event convey a sense of the meaning of life to its participants? What is the meaning it conveys?
  /05 points 15. In what ways did you, as an observer, find this ritual meaningful? In what ways did you find it lacking?
  /05 points 16 .What did this observation teach you about your own beliefs (about human nature, God, the community of believers, etc.)?

C. Evaluation

  /05 points 17. What were the objectives you had set for this observation, and to what degree did you accomplish each of them?
  /05 points 18. Do you think your observation strategy was an appropriate one? How might you adapt this strategy to make the observation more effective/efficient?
  /05 points 19. If you worked with a group, did all of the group members fully participate in this observation? How might you improve the group dynamic? If you did not work with a group, how might that have made the observation more effective?
  /05 points 20. What questions did this observation raise for further research or discussion?
 
Total Points (of 100)
less points for late submission
 
Net Points