Case Study Grading Protocol
last update: 12 December 2007
A. Preliminary Considerations
Fits word limitations? No Yes Comment:
Submitted on or before due date? No Yes Comment:
Adjustments to grade? No Yes If "yes," how much?
B. CRITIQUE OF CONTENT & PRESENTATION
Organization & Format 1 2 3 4  
Introduction        
Orthography & Typography        
Proper Paragraphing        
Sentence Structure        
Conclusion        
Subtotal
  
Description 1 2 3 4  
Background: What is the situation in which the event occurred?        
Who was involved?        
What was the issue/dilemma?        
Where & when did it take place?        
Are there any other relevant factors?  How did you resolve the issue?        
Subtotal
  
Analysis 1 2 3 4  
What issues were at work?        
What were the turning points in the incident?        
Where was there resistance?        
What developmental tasks were involved?        
What changes took place as a result of this incident?        
Subtotal
  
Evaluation 1 2 3 4  
What was your objective in making this decision, and why?          
Did you accomplish what you set out to do? How so and/or how not?          
What kind of ethical reasoning were you using in making this decision?          
How could/should you have done it differently?          
What questions can the class discuss that would be helpful to you in re-evaluating this decision?          
Subtotal
  
Theological Reflection 1 2 3 4  
What religious and ethical issues did the incident involve?        
What does this case say about my understanding of divinity/God?        
What does this case say about my understanding of good and evil?        
What does this case say about my understanding of the church?        
What does this case say about my understanding of human nature?        
Subtotal
  

Total for Part B
Less any adjustments from Part A
Total Score for Paper




= A B C D F